Many owners ask themselves this question: should I choose a collar or harness for my dog? With the incredible amount of walking accessories available on the market, the choice quickly becomes difficult. There are all kinds of collars to dress up your dog’s neck, but there are also harnesses adapted to various types of walks. Faced with this choice, hesitation is understandable.
What is best between a dog collar or harness? What are the advantages of a dog harness? What are the advantages of a dog collar? What is the best choice between a dog collar or a harness?
Many owners wonder which is better between a collar and a harness. To find out what is best for your dog here is some useful information to help you choose between collar and harness. All the information you need to choose a harness or a collar for your dog.
The dog collar: advantages and disadvantages
It is very common and is often the first choice when adopting a dog, the collar comes in many different materials, colors, and styles. The advantages of the dog collar include training the young puppy to walk on a leash. It is a practical accessory but has many limitations that can be dangerous. It is suitable for calm dogs that can walk on their feet and listen to their owner.
But for an excited dog who tends to pull on the leash, the collar can have consequences on the dog’s health. Perhaps you have already observed your dog having difficulty breathing or coughing after pulling on the leash too much? This is because the collar puts a lot of pressure on his throat which makes it difficult for him to breathe and can even suffocate him. In some cases, although rare, this pressure can cause thyroid and cervical problems.
Is the collar suitable for my dog? For a dog that doesn’t pull on his leash and is of a rather calm nature, the collar will be perfectly suitable. It also has the advantage of putting a tag with your contact details, which is practical in case of running away. If you opt for the collar, prefer a leather or nylon material that is more suitable, and avoid collars made of low-quality material or chain collars which are really very uncomfortable for the animal.
In summary, if your dog is the foufou type, the purchase of a harness will be more adapted to his temperament. The harness will allow better support of the animal without hurting him or pressing on his throat when the dog pulls on the leash.
The dog harness: advantages and disadvantages
Dog harnesses are widely recommended, they are suitable for all morphologies and their main advantage is that they do not compress the animal’s throat. Their shape makes them much more comfortable and suitable for all types of walks and sports practices without the risk of injury to the dog.
Moreover, and it’s good to know, the harness is recommended for certain breeds of dogs predisposed to pathologies such as Chiari malformation (Cavalier King Charles, Yorkshire, Dwarf Spitz, Bichon, Miniature Poodle, Pekingese), chondrodystrophy (dachshund, Basset Hound) or hydrocephalus (Chihuahua, Pekingese, English Bulldog, Yorkshire Pug…).
To summarize, here are the main advantages of the dog harness:
A better comfort
Less risk of strangulation
No compression on the throat
More pleasant walks for the animal
Better management control
Practices in case of sports activities
How to choose a dog harness
Favoring the harness is a good thing, but it is still necessary to know how to choose it well. There are many models of harnesses for dogs; some have a bib for better comfort, others have more or less wide straps or one or more attachment points. Not all of them are the same, and the cheap harnesses are generally of poor quality and do not have all the advantages mentioned above.
A poorly chosen or unsuitable harness will have disadvantages for the animal:
Impede your dog’s mobility,
Generate a painful rubbing on the skin,
Make him walk sideways,
Trigger back problems.
For optimal comfort for both the handler and the dog, a harness adapted to the dog and the type of outing should be chosen. There are specific harnesses for the training of young dogs or for the practice of canine sports such as Canirun, if you are in these cases we recommend you choose this specific type of model.
For daily walks and short hikes, the T-shaped harness is the most suitable because of its comfort. This type of harness has straps that do not hinder the dog’s movements and do not put pressure on the throat, it has the advantage of being suitable for small dogs as well as big ones. The Julius-K9 model is the most popular and appreciated in this category, in addition to being affordable.
Y-shaped harnesses are also recommended because their configuration makes strangulation impossible, but they are not suitable for all morphologies. Finally, the H-shaped harness is the most classic but not the safest. It will suit a calm dog who does not pull but does not prevent the strap from compressing the throat on a dog pulling on his leash.